The quotation from Karl Marx about history repeating itself deserves more attention than it is getting. Though it is best to first say that history does NOT repeat itself. HUMANS repeat history by repeating themselves. That is, we human beings do not learn well, or only rarely, from what has gone past.
We continually fall again and again into the same hole, not because of determinism, but due to the fact that we continually react to events in the same way. Experiences are meant to teach us, but they rarely do. We act in a certain way, certain specific results follow, and we complain about the outcome,. Forgetting the fact that whatever we experience is and direct result of our actions. So to change the result, we should change our actions. But we don't.
Hence, when we are confronted with a situation, we find ourselves repeating precisely what we have done before, and then results are same, and we declare that history repeats itself. No. We repeat our reactions to events, and the same result comes up.
This is quite sad, really, since one of the things we are expected to get right is to learn by experience and mature to what we really are : spirit beings. The unsavory situation on our planet earth today bears testimony to the fact that we have not been good learners as yet.
With increasing learning from experience should have come, improved conditions on our planet earth, new and more enriching experiences, rather than mere repetition of old ones in a cyclic repetition of the same events.
This is not to say that new experiences have not come, they have. There has been innovations and discoveries that offer us chances of maturity and experience of new events. But our reactions have merely been variations of the same things, thus history repeats...
Thus, the aggression in us since olden times has not improved into helping love or any other virtue, but has remained the same. Therefore, when we had only crude tools to facilitate our life on earth, we fashioned weapons to better pursue our aggressive tendencies...crude weapons, but weapons anyway. Now that we have grown in technology, away from the credit of stone implements that is, we have not dropped the least of our aggressive tendencies. Hence, we have sophisticated weapons today that are at the cutting edge of technology. And wars remain rampant, only that today, we Have more powerful weapons to vent our aggression. And we declare, of course, that history repeats itself when we are the ones repeating our negative tendencies...
The technology we have today has immensely improved our capacity for good as well as we evil. Unfortunately, we have tended to take the opportunities to be bad, to be worse than before. We have increased our capacity to do evil, when the same effort would have produced greater good. We have not used our experiences to evolve to nobler beings that we can, and must be. Our faults remain. The greed and selfishness that led to the trans -Atlantic Slave Trade has remained intact. Only that today, it has merely mutated into a more subtle for. ..today's slavery is economic, and so history repeats itself as early variant of the slave trade we abolished still thrives, in a different format.
The solution to the phenomenon of history repeating itself is simple: we simply need to act in a different way, and we will keep making ever new history, without repeating anyone, and also keep advancing in maturity, capacity to do good, and actual good. This does not need to start with any leader, it can start with individuals. Individuals choosing to make a difference to how we react to events.
That will relieve us from continually repeating our history.
This is quite sad, really, since one of the things we are expected to get right is to learn by experience and mature to what we really are : spirit beings. The unsavory situation on our planet earth today bears testimony to the fact that we have not been good learners as yet.
With increasing learning from experience should have come, improved conditions on our planet earth, new and more enriching experiences, rather than mere repetition of old ones in a cyclic repetition of the same events.
This is not to say that new experiences have not come, they have. There has been innovations and discoveries that offer us chances of maturity and experience of new events. But our reactions have merely been variations of the same things, thus history repeats...
Thus, the aggression in us since olden times has not improved into helping love or any other virtue, but has remained the same. Therefore, when we had only crude tools to facilitate our life on earth, we fashioned weapons to better pursue our aggressive tendencies...crude weapons, but weapons anyway. Now that we have grown in technology, away from the credit of stone implements that is, we have not dropped the least of our aggressive tendencies. Hence, we have sophisticated weapons today that are at the cutting edge of technology. And wars remain rampant, only that today, we Have more powerful weapons to vent our aggression. And we declare, of course, that history repeats itself when we are the ones repeating our negative tendencies...
The technology we have today has immensely improved our capacity for good as well as we evil. Unfortunately, we have tended to take the opportunities to be bad, to be worse than before. We have increased our capacity to do evil, when the same effort would have produced greater good. We have not used our experiences to evolve to nobler beings that we can, and must be. Our faults remain. The greed and selfishness that led to the trans -Atlantic Slave Trade has remained intact. Only that today, it has merely mutated into a more subtle for. ..today's slavery is economic, and so history repeats itself as early variant of the slave trade we abolished still thrives, in a different format.
The solution to the phenomenon of history repeating itself is simple: we simply need to act in a different way, and we will keep making ever new history, without repeating anyone, and also keep advancing in maturity, capacity to do good, and actual good. This does not need to start with any leader, it can start with individuals. Individuals choosing to make a difference to how we react to events.
That will relieve us from continually repeating our history.